A woman described as emotionally disturbed stabbed one man and one woman in Times Square on Monday afternoon, leaving both victims in critical condition. Police shot the suspect after she refused orders to drop two knives and pointed a weapon at officers. The incident occurred near Seventh Avenue, though reports differ on the exact cross street.
No left-leaning sources covered this
No center sources covered this
The incident highlights gaps in mental health services and the need for crisis intervention teams rather than immediate lethal force.
“Systemic failures in community care and use-of-force protocols”
The attack shows ongoing public safety failures in New York City and the necessity of decisive police action against armed threats.
“Lenient approaches to disorder and the value of empowered law enforcement”
The stabbings violate individual rights through unprovoked violence, while gun restrictions leave bystanders reliant on delayed police response.
“Initiation of force and limits of state monopoly on protection”
All perspectives adopt the 'emotionally disturbed' framing to advance policy arguments while overlooking the location dispute and lack of evidence on prior contacts.
“Shared narrative structure that prioritizes ideology over unexamined details like response timing near a police post”
Ratings by MBFC