All available details on the Karmelo Anthony murder conviction, sentencing, and judicial recusal stem from a single unverified New York Post account. The reports claim Anthony, now 19, was convicted of murdering 17-year-old Austin Metcalf, sentenced to 35 years, and that a new judge will review a retrial motion after the original judge's removal. No independent court records, police documents, or additional outlets corroborate any element of the narrative.