James Gunn stated a commitment to storytelling priorities for the DCU, with Milly Alcock cast as Supergirl. Forbes reported that reviews from Variety, The Guardian, and the Los Angeles Times have led some observers to question the project's prospects. Multiple outlets have published pieces on the film prior to release.
No left-leaning sources covered this
No center sources covered this
“‘Supergirl’ Reviews Have Some Writing Off James Gunn’s DCU Already - Forbes”
Read at Forbes →Early negative coverage risks reinforcing gatekeeping against female-led and inclusive superhero stories before release.
“Heightened scrutiny of departures from male-centric formulas and corporate risk aversion”
The coverage signals another potential DCU stumble driven by critics favoring ideological priorities over broad narrative appeal.
“Pattern of reboots struggling to recapture traditional heroism amid media influence”
Decentralized audience choice will ultimately determine the project's success regardless of critic commentary.
“Voluntary exchange and speech freedoms over centralized studio or institutional mandates”
All perspectives accept the Forbes premise of substantive early dismissal without evidence of its scale or whether reviews address a finished film.
“Shared assumption that critic reactions carry decisive weight, ignoring Gunn's history of leveraging controversy and the lack of predictive data”
Ratings by MBFC