An essay by Aaron MacLean published in The Free Press draws on Shakespeare’s St. Crispin’s Day speech, Herman Wouk’s War and Remembrance, and a 1973 Gore Vidal essay to frame Memorial Day around combat bonds and literary tradition. All cited details remain unverified across the two available sources. Coverage is limited to right-center outlets.
No left-leaning sources covered this
No center sources covered this
“‘We band of brothers:’ A Memorial Day meditation”
Read at New York Post →Frames the essay as romanticizing combat while ignoring who serves and post-1945 policy costs.
“Structural inequalities and preventable casualties”
Presents the essay as affirming martial brotherhood and national continuity through veteran perspective.
“Respect for military tradition and lived experience”
Highlights voluntary individual bonds over state-directed narratives.
“Personal agency versus institutional power”
Notes that all views accept unverified claims and overlook insulation from policy scrutiny.
“Unexamined factual scaffolding and selective literary framing”
Ratings by MBFC